Answers to Questions by Yair Davidiy
What is the problem with having a secular democratic state in the Land of Israel for everyone?
- Create a secular democratic state in the Land of Israel including West Bank and Gaza.
- Allow only those who are persecuted and those whose skills are needed to migrate whether they are Jews or not.
- Give everyone the same rights.
- Open holy sites for all.
What's the problem with this solution?
The Jews and Arabs do not want such a solution.
Â In Arab eyes being Arab and being secular and democratic is a contradiction in terms. There are no Arab secular democratic states. They do not want any.
Â The Arab belongs to the Islamic People. It defines to himself what he is.
The Jews could live in a secular democratic state in so far that a majority of the populace could conceivably be misled to agree to it.
Â The Jews however are in the Land MOST OF ALL because the Bible and the Jewish Religion has given them the right to be there.
Â This right entails obligations. Denying the obligations undermines the right for Jews to exist in Israel and ultimately anywhere else.
Â Ask the Germans.